I've been to lots of flamenco gigs over the last few years. But only now have I thought about reviewing them. And quite honestly, I don't feel very comfortable doing it. After all, I'm still learning...and what do I know? Do I have any right to critique someone's art, something I know they have dedicated their life to...way more so than I have & God knows I've put in some hours. So I say this with an acknowledgment of their expertise, their commitment and my own subjectivity.
The show had two halves, both structured in a similar way: 3 or 4 pieces, starting with song or guitar, then song with guitar, then with dance. I though the guitarist was great, Jesus Guerrero. Young and light fingered he played beautifully. Now I don't always think flamenco guitar should be beautiful, sometimes it benefits from being passionate, exciting, chaotic...but that wasn't his style. He played a great solea and I wish there was more of him. The dancer was unusual, lots of hips and angles. With a focus on shapes and body structure, it reminded me more of contemporary dance than the flamenco I'm familiar with. The singer had an intense vibratto and indeed great intensity. Again, I'm more familiar with a more robust sound, with more definition and certainly a less pronounced vibratto. I felt it got in the way. Overall though I didn't really connect with it. it was probably very technical but I wasn't carried along, there was no narrative to the structure, it didn't build and I didn't find myself carried along. it was kind of rational, and maybe technically excellent. Not my cup of tea. Which is sad because I took some friends & they were polite but I want them to see that flamenco can be a truly trans formative experience. This wasn't. So we'll go searching for something else.